Samuel Catlin Case, brother of Emma Lane, was working as a section foreman for the Southern Kansas Railroad in 1889 when his wife, Emily Jean Townsend Case, and daughter, Hallie
Antoinette (Mrs. A.A. Tiemann), came from Garnett, Kansas, to join him at Sutton (formerly Glasgow).
Emily said that the trip from Kansas, called the Cherokee Run, was practically the same as pictured in the
movie production of Cimarron.
-
In a newspaper article, "Coyotes and Cowboys Clearly Recalled by Pioneer Woman," Emily told about her arrival at Sutton:
"My husband met me with a lantern,
and as we walked down a cow trail, I saw a light which came from a dugout in which Mr. and Mrs. T.H. Lane were living temporarily. Their family was the first to live at the railroad station, and ours was the second. We
took up some state land at $1 an acre with forty years to pay.
"We lived with the Lane family until my husband, working evenings, was able to build a rude hut out of foot lumber, Tin cans, employed as a
covering, helped to keep out the winds, which seemed to be even stronger then than now. Most of our furniture was made at home but a stove and bed were sent from other points. In order to have a guest room,
however, we built a bunk like that typical of cowboy life.
"We went to Kiowa, Kansas, once each month to do our shopping and we would buy enough food, clothing and other necessities to last until
the next month. Water and coal were shipped to this territory."
On June 1, 1887, Sam Case had received the Doctor of Medicine degree from the American Medical College at St. Louis, but he chose not to
practice that profession. The family story is that he was sent to intern in an insane asylum and found the experience so unnerving that he said he could never doctor humanity again. His medical diploma and his doctor's
prescription scale for pocket or valise are in the museum.
Also in the musuem is a pair of yearling size buffalo horns which Emily found about 1890. The horns were polished by a man who worked for the railroad
The railroad station known as Sutton in 1889 was located on White Deer Lands, an area of 631,000 acres in Hutchinson, Carson, Gray and Roberts Counties. About 14 miles southwest of Sutton, the manager, George
Tyng, was living on the demonstration farm of the company. On December 1, 1889, Tyng wrote a detailed report to trustee Frederic Foster in New York.
"The present year (1889) has not offered inducements
for putting White Deer Lands upon the market, but indications all point to the beginning of 1890 of a satisfactory demand for them.
"We want some kind of village from which to sell lands in Roberts and
Gray Counties. These lands are not conveniently accessible to White Deer Farm, nor from Miami and not at all so from Panhandle, but they would be very easily got at from a village at Sutton, on the railroad laid out on
survey 102, block 3 in Gray County.
"A boarding house, livery stable, and grocery and variety store, backed by a railroad station, telegraph and post office, are great helps to the sale of nearby lands. They
(settlers) would all come quickly enough if we let down the bars and give invitation.
"It will not cost very much to plot and survey out a town at Sutton, and not so very much more to drill a well there
for supplying water to travelers, visitors and first residents. Probably no direct great profit could be made out of the town; nor should that be the intention. The motive should be that of adding value and hastening
sale of surrounding lands. "
Nearly 18 months passed before the British stockholders of White Deer Lands agreed to Tyng's proposal to start a town at Sutton. Tyng reported the progress of this
undertaking in his letters to Foster.
June 1, 1891 - (after a big hail) ".The well-boring outfit is on the way to Sutton ... probably stuck in the mud. Before contracting for that well, I waited
to see what the season (for wheat) is really going to be ... it is going to be good enough. Field notes and working sketch of Block 3 will be here this week and the section surveys will begin at once."
September 4, 1891 - "Having had some experience of the disappointments and petty annoyances of trying to make civilized things in out of the way uncivilized places, I look forward to the next two months at Sutton
without extravagent delight. The owner may with similar feelings look back on them and their cost in case results do not realize my expectations. But in this part of the world things really do look better and more
promising than I had expected to find them.
"We need right now in Gray County some place in which men and animals can sleep, eat and drink, to which we can bring buyers and from which they can go to see
and we to show what we have to sell."
September 27, 1891 - "Sutton is a school in which I am learning self control. I have heretofore partly described to you the difficulties presented to
settlement by isolation. I am there feeling them, such as would drive or ruin any settler not stubborn and well fixed.
"Am going to Sutton in the morning. Am sorry you encourage me to spend money at
Sutton; fresh expense crops up, and in meeting it I shall appear to be taking advantage of your tolerance. "
October 3, 1891 - "My Sutton Frankenstein has not yet quite succeeded in destroying me
though it is a harder master than I had expected. The railroad persisted in taking my stuff to the other Sutton (Sutton County on the Edwards Plateau in southwest Texas) and delay and costs are maddening. However, I
have a nice lot of men and the future of Sutton promises to amply compensate the throes of its parturition. The inertia of the wheat crop is gradually being overcome; one hundred acres are in and growing
nicely. The rest will follow quickly as soon as the ground gets dry enough for mules to walk in it."